What are the deductible business expenses for sole proprietors? How to think about entertainment expenses, meeting expenses, and welfare expenses, and examples of denial
As a sole proprietor, you may find yourself wondering, "Can I deduct this expense?" This is especially true for entertainment, meeting, and employee welfare expenses, which can often blur the line with personal expenses. If you make the wrong judgment, your expenses may be disallowed during a tax audit, leading to additional taxes.
In this article, we will cover the basic concepts of entertainment, meeting, and employee welfare expenses that sole proprietors should pay particular attention to when booking expenses, the differences compared to corporations, and actual rulings and court cases where expenses were not recognized as necessary. If you've been "just booking expenses without really thinking about it," now is the time to clarify your criteria.
Basic Concepts of Deductible Expenses for Sole Proprietors
According to Article 37 of the Income Tax Act, deductible expenses for sole proprietors are defined as "expenses directly incurred to generate total income" and "expenses incurred for the business that generates that income." The key point is whether the expense was "directly necessary for the conduct of the business."
On the other hand, Article 45 of the Income Tax Act stipulates that "household expenses and expenses related thereto" cannot be included as deductible expenses. Expenses related to living costs, hobbies, or social activities that are not clearly related to the business fall under these "household-related expenses" and are not recognized as deductible.
The reason why entertainment, meeting, and employee welfare expenses are problematic is precisely because they are expenses that lie on the borderline between "expenses directly necessary for the business" and "household-related expenses." Let's examine the concepts for each in the following sections.
Entertainment Expenses - Treatment Differs Significantly Between Corporations and Sole Proprietors
Entertainment expenses are costs incurred for entertaining clients, suppliers, and other business-related parties through hospitality, entertainment, or gifts. What's important here is that the tax treatment of entertainment expenses is completely different for corporations and sole proprietors.
Corporations: There is a limit, but the category of "entertainment expenses" itself is recognized.
For corporations, entertainment expenses generally cannot be included in deductible expenses (costs) due to Article 61-4 of the Act on Special Measures Concerning Taxation. However, for small and medium-sized corporations (corporations that meet requirements such as a capital of 100 million yen or less at the end of the term), expenses up to 8 million yen per year are allowed to be expensed (included in deductible expenses). In other words, it's like a corporation having a pre-defined expenditure category called "entertainment expenses" with a set upper limit.
Sole proprietors: No upper limit, but difficult to prove "business relevance."
Sole proprietors do not have a special category for entertainment expenses. Instead, expenses are judged based on whether they fall under "directly necessary for the conduct of business" (Article 37 of the Income Tax Act). While there is no upper limit, the line between personal and business expenses can become blurred, making the burden of proof for business relevance heavier compared to corporations.
Key Point: Although entertainment expenses for sole proprietors can theoretically be expensed without an upper limit, it is essential to be able to objectively explain "whether the expenditure was truly for business purposes." It is important to accumulate evidence, such as noting the names and relationships of the parties involved, the purpose of the meeting, and writing the purpose on receipts.
| Comparison Items | Corporation | Sole Proprietor |
|---|---|---|
| Basis of Concept | Article 61-4 of the Act on Special Measures Concerning Taxation (Non-deductibility of Entertainment Expenses, etc.) | Article 37 (Necessary Expenses) and Article 45 (Household-Related Expenses) of the Income Tax Act |
| Upper Limit | Generally non-deductible. Small and medium-sized corporations can expense up to 8 million yen per year. | No upper limit specified |
| Practical Issues | Whether the amount falls within the system's framework | Whether business relevance can be proven |
Additionally, there is a category close to entertainment expenses called meeting expenses. Meeting expenses refer to expenses for refreshments, bento boxes, and meeting room rentals that are considered reasonable within social norms when conducting business discussions or negotiations. The difference from entertainment expenses can be judged by two points: ① whether there is an element of entertainment or hospitality, and ② whether it is within the scope of social norms. Light refreshments accompanying a simple discussion can be categorized as meeting expenses, but if the primary purpose is dining or if it involves a high-class meal, it is more likely to be judged as entertainment expenses (or household-related expenses). Be aware that internal meeting expenses are often not recognized as deductible expenses if there are no employees.
Employee Welfare Expenses - Points Sole Proprietors Often Misunderstand
Employee welfare expenses are costs aimed at improving the comfort, health, and living standards of employees. Examples include year-end parties, health check-up costs, and condolence or congratulatory payments. Sole proprietors should pay particular attention to the following points.
- Employee welfare expenses are "expenses for employees" and, in principle, do not apply to the business owner themselves. Sole proprietors who do not have employees, or only have family employees (dependents), cannot book their own health check-up fees or meal expenses as employee welfare expenses.
- Even if you have employees, it must be a uniform system that covers all employees. Expenses for specific executives or employees may be treated as salary or entertainment expenses.
- Be careful about the distinction between expenses for full-time employees that should be treated as full-time employee salaries in principle, and those that can be treated as welfare expenses.
- Travel allowances (daily allowances) cannot be considered necessary expenses because the concept of paying them to the sole proprietor themselves does not exist. Only actual expenses such as transportation and accommodation costs incurred are necessary expenses. If you have employees, you can establish travel expense regulations for them, pay them a daily allowance, and include it as a necessary expense.
- Even if you have employees, the portion of costs incurred for the business owner and their blue-form certified employee for company trips (recreational trips) cannot be treated as welfare expenses in principle. Please note that trips solely for the business owner or only for the business owner and their certified employee are likely to be considered private family trips and will not be recognized as welfare expenses.
There are many misunderstandings, such as 'Because I'm a sole proprietor, I can treat my own recreational trips and health checkups as welfare expenses.' Sole proprietors who are the sole operator without any employees should be particularly careful.
Rulings and court cases where expenses were not actually recognized as necessary expenses
From here, we will introduce rulings and court cases where expenses were actually denied as necessary expenses. Please use these as examples to understand cases where expenses are not recognized for tax purposes, even if you feel they contribute to the business.
Membership fees for Rotary Clubs, Lions Clubs, etc.
Many sole proprietors want to deduct membership fees for social clubs like Rotary Clubs and Lions Clubs as necessary expenses, reasoning that it expands their network and leads to business. However, the National Tax Tribunal and courts have consistently ruled against this.
- There is a ruling that did not allow the inclusion of Rotary Club membership fees paid by a certified public accountant or tax accountant in necessary expenses (Ruling dated January 27, 1983).
- There is a ruling that denied the deductibility of Rotary Club membership fees paid by a lawyer as necessary expenses (Ruling dated July 19, 2016). This decision was ultimately upheld by the Supreme Court (Decision dated June 26, 2020).
- There is a ruling that denied the deductibility of Rotary Club initiation fees and membership fees paid by a judicial scrivener as necessary expenses (Ruling dated March 6, 2014).
What is common to all these cases is the idea that "activities as a member of a club, when viewed objectively in light of social norms, are not recognized as being directly related to the business and necessary for its execution." It is important to note that even if there is an indirect effect such as networking, it is not evaluated as an expense directly necessary for business operations.
Furthermore, among the published decisions of the National Tax Tribunal, there is a case where the inclusion of various membership fees paid by an individual business owner engaged in dental practice as necessary expenses was not permitted, stating that "it is not possible to clarify the part directly necessary for the execution of the business" (Decision dated March 30, 2001, Collection of Decision Cases No. 61). This shows that regardless of the industry, membership fees with a strong social character are unlikely to be recognized as necessary expenses.
On the other hand, membership fees for chambers of commerce and industry and corporate associations differ in nature from these social clubs. Fees that can specifically explain their relationship to the business, such as gathering industry information and building networks with business partners, are generally recognized as necessary expenses. It is important to remember that expenses judged to be solely for private purposes cannot be expensed, and this point should be kept in mind as well.
Tuition fees for obtaining qualifications
There is a case where an individual business owner operating a bone-setting clinic included tuition fees for attending a vocational school to obtain a judo therapist qualification as necessary expenses, but this was denied by the tax office (Osaka District Court, judgment dated October 25, 2019).
The ruling evaluated the tuition fees as "an expenditure to create a foundation for earning income as a judo therapist in the future" and as having "the effect of increasing the value of human capital, which is not included in income, by obtaining a license that monopolizes the profession." As a result, it was determined that the expenses were not directly related to the business at the time of expenditure and were not necessary for its execution.
Similarly, there is a case where an individual business owner engaged in the legal profession included tuition fees for master's and doctoral programs at graduate schools and donations to overseas universities as necessary expenses, but these were determined to be non-deductible business expenses related to the legal profession (Decision dated October 27, 2003, Collection of Decision Cases No. 66).
Key Point: What can be learned from these cases is that the criterion for determining necessary expenses is not "whether it contributes to future sales" but "whether it is directly necessary for conducting the current business." Expenses for acquiring qualifications or degrees are less likely to be recognized as necessary expenses if they have a strong investment nature prior to starting the business.
Golf fees disguised as entertainment
There is a case where an individual business owner engaged in the real estate rental business deducted golf fees (including those for companions and dining expenses) at a golf club as entertainment expenses. However, the deduction was not permitted because the business-relatedness could not be confirmed (Decision dated April 22, 2010). In this case, it was determined that the expenses were personal expenses that were not directly related to the performance of the business, as the individual was merely playing golf with a professional golfer to whom they had personally requested lessons.
Key Point: Even for golf expenses, there is a possibility they may be recognized as entertainment expenses if there is actual evidence and records of entertaining business partners. However, if you cannot objectively explain the companions, purpose, and details of the business discussions, it is a high-risk item that may be deemed personal expenses disguised as "entertainment."
Summary: Key Points for Individual Business Owners to Consider When Determining Expenses
| Expense Item | Point of Judgment |
|---|---|
| Entertainment Expenses | While there is no upper limit like for corporations, proving business relevance is essential. Keep records of the parties involved and the purpose. |
| Meeting Expenses | Whether it is within a reasonable range according to social norms, without elements of entertainment or hospitality. |
| Employee Welfare Expenses | In principle, it cannot be used for the business owner themselves. It must be a uniform system that covers all employees. |
| Business Trip Allowances & Company Trips | In principle, expenses for the business owner and their full-time family employees cannot be treated as employee welfare expenses. |
| Social Club Dues | Indirect benefits like networking are insufficient. Treated differently from industry associations like Chambers of Commerce and Industry or business associations. |
| Qualification Acquisition Costs & Degree Acquisition Costs | Investments for future business development are distinguished from necessary expenses for the current business. |
| Expenses for Entertainment Purposes (e.g., Golf Fees) | If the reality of entertainment cannot be objectively explained, it will be deemed a personal expense. |
Compared to corporations, individual business owners do not have a "clear upper limit" for necessary expenses, making it all the more important to be able to explain the business relevance themselves. When you are unsure about an expense, it is better to organize it in advance rather than scrambling after being pointed out during a tax audit. This will lead to peace of mind.
For those who wish to know more details, please feel free to contact us. We would also appreciate it if you could take a look at our services and fees.
